Penetrant Testing : advantages and disadvantages

oilandgas blog
In this blog, we have explained some Advantages and Disadvantages of Penetrant Testing along with this we have also mentioned many useful Penetrant Testing like all nondestructive inspection methods, liquid penetrant inspection has both advantages and disadvantages. The primary advantages and disadvantages when compared to other NDE methods are summarized below. Large areas and large volumes of parts/materials be inspected rapidly and at low cost. if you want to get a whole idea about the Advantages and Disadvantages of Penetrant Testing make sure to check it till the end

Which is an advantage of penetrant testing?

  • The method is sensitive to small variations in the surface where it is used. 
  • The method has very little materials restrictions – metallic and nonmetallic, magnetic and nonmagnetic, and conductor or non-conductor materials may be checked. 

Penetrant Testing Primary advantages:

  • Large areas and large volumes of parts/materials are inspected rapidly and at low cost.
  •  Cross sections of miscellaneous forms are checked frequently in components. 
  •  Indications are made on the surface of the part and are a reproduction of the flaw in every sense. 
  •  Anyone who uses penetrant materials is always able to spray it using aerosol spray meaning that the material can always be transported easily. 
  •  Penetrant materials and equipment connected with them, as has been said, are rather cheap. 

Penetrant Testing Primary disadvantages:

  • In association with that, only those that break the surface can be discerned. 
  • It is necessary to emphasize that the part of the material’s surface to be inspected must be as dense as possible. 
  • Pre-cleaning is important because one cannot tell the difference between flaws and dirt. 
  • Any metallic debris from the procedures such as machining, grinding or grit/vapor blasting must be first cleaned prior to LPI. 
  • An appropriate position of the inspector implies that he or she should be able to work on the surface being inspected. 
  • Surface finish of a part and roughness of the surface do influence the limit of an inspector’s sensitivity. 
  • Several processes need to be run and regulated concurrently. 
  • Some additional requirements that should be met are post cleaning of acceptable parts or materials. 
  • Element handling and disposal is necessary.

what is dye penetrant testing

Dye penetrant testing (DPT) is one of non-destructive testing (NDT) which is applied for the detection of surface break flaws on materials. DPT functions by using a dye penetrant on the surface of the material being tested. The contacts of the penetrant and the material take place and the dye penetrant is drawn into any flaw in the material. Afterwards, the surface is washed to get rid of the extra dye penetrant after a dwell time. A developer is then applied on the surface. The developer removes as well as draws the dye penetrant out of the defects, which makes them to be seen. 

It is possible to use DPT on samples of metal, plastics or composite material samples. It is widely applied to assess welds, castings and forgings as well as other parts of the product. Besides the above types of parts, DPT can also be applied in evaluating other parts such as gears, bearings and seals. 

DPT is comparatively a simple and cheap method within the context of NDT techniques. It is also a very informative and precise method, which easily identifies even the smallest of defects. But to the contrary, DPT is not fit for detecting all kinds of faults. And it is not appropriate for testing materials that are either porous or have a rough surface. 

Here is a step-by-step overview of the DPT process:

  1. Clean the area of the material that is to be tested. This helps in wiping off any form of dirt, oil or any other particle that might in any way affect the test. 
  2. Brush the dye penetrant onto the surface of the material. The dye penetrant is usually sprayed or painted on the part to be inspected. 
  3. Let the dye penetrant stay on the surface for a certain amount of time. This enables the dye penetrant to get into any crack of the given material through which the fluid can pass through. 
  4. Wipe off the superfluous dye penetrant from the surface of the test piece. This is done mostly by dissolving the sample in a solvent or using water. 
  5. Rub the developer solution onto the surface. The developer of the developed Standard removes the dye penetrant out of the defects in the material and they become visible. 
  6. Check the surface of the material for dings and scratches as well as other damage. Defects will appear as dark lines or areas on the surface of the material or aluminum clad metal.

DPT can be regarded as an efficient NDT method, which can be used for the detection of various kinds of defects on the surface of materials. It is economical, simple to carry out, and very sensitive and can be applied in both general and specific studies. 


 

liquid penetrant testing can be used to detect

Liquid penetrant testing (LPT), also known as dye penetrant testing (DPT), is used to detect various surface-related defects and discontinuities in materials, especially metals and non-porous ceramics. Some of the common defects and issues that liquid penetrant testing can be used to detect include:

Cracks: LPT is highly effective in identifying both shallow and deep cracks on the surface of a material. This includes fatigue cracks, stress corrosion cracks, and other types of crack formations.

Porosity: The method can detect pores, voids, or gas pockets that may exist on the material's surface or just beneath it.

Laps and Seams: LPT can locate laps (overlapping materials) and seams (areas where two surfaces meet) that might not be properly bonded or joined.

Inclusions: It is capable of finding foreign materials or particles embedded in the surface of the material, which may affect its structural integrity.

Weld Defects: LPT is commonly used to inspect welds for defects such as lack of fusion, incomplete penetration, undercutting, and cracks in or near the weld.

Casting Defects: It can identify defects in castings, such as shrinkage voids, gas porosity, and sand inclusions.

Surface Discontinuities: LPT can find various surface irregularities, including scratches, gouges, and grinding or machining marks.

Fatigue Damage: The method can detect surface indications related to fatigue damage, which can occur due to repeated stress cycles over time.

Heat Damage: It can reveal heat-affected zones and thermal stress cracks caused by welding or other high-temperature processes.

Corrosion: LPT can locate corrosion pits and other forms of surface corrosion that may weaken the material.

Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC): It is effective in identifying stress corrosion cracks, which are a specific type of crack caused by the combination of tensile stress and corrosive environments.

Surface Hardening Irregularities: It can uncover inconsistencies in surface hardening processes, which are used to improve wear resistance.

Liquid penetrant testing is a valuable non-destructive testing (NDT) method for detecting these surface-related defects and discontinuities. It is widely used across industries to ensure the safety and quality of critical components and structures. However, it's important to note that LPT primarily focuses on surface defects and may not detect defects or discontinuities beneath the material's surface. For deeper inspections, other NDT methods like radiographic testing or ultrasonic testing may be required.

NDT penetrant testing procedure

The following is a step-by-step overview of the non-destructive testing (NDT) penetrant testing procedure:

  1. Before using the material in the experiment, it is advisable to wash it. This washes away any grime, oils or any material that would in any way affect the test that is being done on the sample.
  2. Spread the dye penetrant on the surface of the material that is to be inspected by this method. In using the dye penetrant, a spray gun or brush is mostly used in the application of the dye penetrant.
  3. There is also a setting time which simply means allow the dye penetrant to rest on the surface for a little while. This results in the dye penetrant to enter into the defects that there are in the material.
  4. After the dye penetrant has spread over the surface, wash off the extra dye penetrant. This is usually done employing a solvent or water.
  5. Rub the developer onto the surface. In this case, the developer withdraws the dye penetrant from the defects in the material rendering them to be easily seen.
  6. An analysis of the surface of the material should be done with attention being placed to possible flaws. The flaws will always be prominent as a black line or a number of black areas on the cross-section of the material.

Here are some additional details about each step of the procedure:

Cleaning the surface 

The surface of the material that will be tested should firstly be clean to any dirt before the application of the dye penetrant. This gets rid of any form of deposits that acts as a barrier on the skin's surface such as dirt, oil and any other material that may affect the result. Solvent cleaning, abrasive cleaning and the use of the cleaner, the ultrasonic are various methods that one can use to clean the surface. 

Applying the dye penetrant 

The dye penetrant is normally applied to the surface of the material by spraying or application of paint brush whereby the inspection is to be made. The other limitation is that with dye penetrants, a given surface to be inspected should be well covered. 

Dwelling time 

The dwell time is the time that the dye penetrant is given to remain on the surface of the material before wet wipe. The dwell time is normally defined in the dye penetrant’s specification or is recommended by the dye penetrant manufacturer. 

Here, one can learn how to remove the excess dye penetrant to make sure the result achieved is the best. 

The penetrant that has excess to the surface of the material is withdrawn by means of a solvent or water. Excess DPI can be wiped off, dipped off, or sprayed off to free any surface that has been checked with DPI. 

Applying the developer 

Developer is sprayed or wiped on the surface of the material once all the excessive penetrant has been washed off. This to and fro process forces the dye penetrant out of the defects in the material hence making them conspicuous. 

Inspecting the surface 

The material is then analyzed for visible imperfections on the surface after the developer has been applied. More specifically, the defects will manifest in the pasty material where they will appear as dark lines or regions. 

The NDT penetrant testing is one of the simplest and efficient techniques in the assessment of the surface breaking discontinuities in the material. Thus, it can be used as a tool in almost all fields like aerospace, automotive, and manufacturing. 


 

NDT penetrant testing

Non-destructive testing (NDT) penetrant testing, often referred to as dye penetrant testing (DPT) or liquid penetrant testing (LPT) is a general and popular method for detection of surface flaws, the cracking and other discontinuity of the material mainly in metals and non porous ceramics.Here's an overview of NDT penetrant testing:

Principle: The method of penetrant testing involves the use of a penetrant which is absorbed by capillary into the surface and gets into the opening and defects. It is then made noticeable when the developer is applied, which raises from the point where the penetrant has been trapped and forms indications to the surface.

Procedure:

 Surface Preparation: 

  • At the beginning of the process the surface of the material to be tested should be cleaned foundantly. Divestment: Contaminants, oils, dirt, and scale are some of the entities that may hinder the test, and this cleaning process will eliminate them. 

 Penetrant Application: 

  • After that, a red penetrant or fluorescent one, if the penetrant is to be examined under UV light, is applied to the clean surface. The penetrant is allowed to wick its ways through any surface openings and defects through the help of capillary action. 

 Dwell Time: 

  • In particular, after the application of the penetrant WP 1 , the penetrant is left to work into the surface for some time called the “dwell time”. 

 Excess Penetrant Removal: 

  • Once the dwell time has been reached the excess penetrant is washed or wiped off the surface. This can be achieved by use of solvent or an emulsifier depending on the penetrant to be applied out of the two. The aim is to wash out the superfluous penetrant without affecting the one that has been penetrated in the defects. 


 

 Developer Application: 

  • Application of a white, powdery developer takes place. Developer behaves as a blotter and pulls trapped penetrants off the defects and creates clear indications on the surface. Also, they should maintain even and complete coverage. 

 Development Time: 

  • Give the developer some time to sit down and develop as per the set time. This time may vary according to whether a liquid penetrant or an electromagnetic penetrant is being used and the particular method of testing. 

 Indication Inspection: 

  • Normally, conduct the inspection under appropriate lighting conditions, which in this case would be white light or ultraviolet light for fluorescent penetrant materials. As a result of that process, any indications or defects which are visible when the penetrant is of a different color to the material being tested will become clearly evident against the dark background created by the developer. 

 Evaluation: 

  • This entails assessing the indications with regard to their size, shape and location of the indications. Identify the kinds of defects and the importance thereof. Regarding the specification of indications, one can partition indications as conforming or non-conforming to a certain industry standard. 

 Reporting and Documentation: 

  • Record the findings of the penetrant test together with the location and types of indications obtained. Present a detailed report that has to contain suggestions about the actions that need to be taken further, this may include repair work or retest. 

Applications: NDT penetrant testing application is apparent in many industries such as aerospace, automobile, manufacturing, and civil engineering for components and structure and welds inspection for surface flaw. It is a useful means to an end when it comes to guaranteeing the quality and security of important parts and constructs. 

Limitations: Penetrant testing mainly deals with surface defects and hence, does not reveal defects or lack of continuity at a subsurface of the material. However, for more detailed inspection, the other types of NDT like the radiographic testing or even the ultrasonic testing may be needed. 

liquid penetrant testing advantages and disadvantages

Liquid penetrant testing (LPT), dye penetrant testing (DPT) and penetrant inspection are terms that refer to the same technique, which is widely used in the identification of surface defects/discontinuities in the material. Like any NDT technique, it comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages:As with any other NDT method there are some strengths and weaknesses inherent to X-ray methods: 

Advantages: 

High Sensitivity: LPT is very much dependent on the surface finish, crack, porosity and other surface defects which may cause the beam to be reflected. It can detect problems that cannot be detected by the human eyes such as the one illustrated in the picture. 

Versatility: It can be used on a great number of materials including metals, plastics, ceramics and composites. 

Simple and Cost-Effective: LPT is also relatively simple and it does not require a lot of tools and equipment which are expensive. It is comparatively cheaper than some of the other methods used in NDT. 

Minimal Surface Preparation: Surface cleaning is necessary though it is not as rigorous as is the case with some of the other NDT methods such as the magnetic particle inspection. 

Wide Range of Applications: LPT is employed in aerospace, automotive, manufacturing and construction industries for inspection of the components, welds and structures. 

Immediate Results: It can be easily noticed right after the testing and that is why the decision can be made on the further actions quite quickly. 

Detects Subsurface Defects: On some occasions, LPT can reveal surface features on the specimen which are connected with sub-surface cracks and help in identifying area of the damaged material. 

Disadvantages: 

Surface Defect Focus: LPT is mainly the examination of surface and hence failure to identify flaws or discontinuities that are hidden underneath the surface of the material. This is not fit for inspection of internal or subsurface cracks as may be the case with some components. 

Limited to Non-Porous Materials: The LPT gives the best results on non-porous materials. It is relatively less effective on porous materials because the penetrants may be trapped and absorbed in the material and this will make the instrument give wrong results. 

 Environmental Impact: It entails the use of certain chemicals such as penetrants and developers that are detrimental to the health of the environment and the human being. Disposal and handling of the same should be done in the right manner. 

Human Error: Because of this, the LPT has been held to have the potential of bringing about large differences in the outcomes in terms of the proficiency of the holder of the equipment involved. Some of the limits include, possibility of the following human errors: while applying the work, while interpreting work, while documenting the work hence will lead to wrong conclusions. 

Limited to Visible Surface: They should be reachable and visible by the naked eye so that the technician does not have a hard time examining the surface. This is probably not wise especially if the shapes are more complicated and especially if some parts of the work are difficult to reach. 

Time-Consuming: This can actually take a very long time and if it is to be done on large components that may have complex cross sections, or very large areas to cover the time may even be even longer. This may result in either a longer time being taken in matters of inspection or a compromise on quality of work. 

Limited to Detectable Size: Customers also had some concerns with LPT because it is not comfortable to get very small or slim defects or those that are almost on the surface of the part or component. 

Thus, it can be stated that LPT is a relatively efficient NDT method that can be recommended in the given cases if different sorts of SBFs in the given materials are searched. The method is quite easy to execute and equally does not require a lot of resources to be used and it can be applied in all types of sampling. Nevertheless, some restrictions have to be examined before proceeding with this method based on the following limitations of LPT. 

Here are some additional tips for using LPT effectively:

  • Use a high-quality dye penetrant and developer.
  • Clean the surface of the material thoroughly before applying the dye penetrant.
  • Apply the dye penetrant evenly to the surface.
  • Allow the dye penetrant to dwell on the surface for the recommended amount of time.
  • Remove the excess dye penetrant thoroughly.
  • Apply the developer evenly to the surface.
  • Inspect the surface immediately after applying the developer.

The tips above can help the chances of identifying defects with LPT so that the organization can benefit from it. 

Thus, liquid penetrant testing can be considered as the efficient method of NDT to find surface defects in a vast number of materials and components. Nevertheless, its limitations are always crucial to address, such as its applicability for surface defects only and the necessity of appropriate preparation of the surface and the chemicals used. Thus, for other types of inspections, other modern NDT methods including radiographic testing or ultrasonic testing can be used. 


 

Table of Contents